Series 9 Episode 8 discussion
|
30-11-2010, 01:04 PM
(This post was last modified: 30-11-2010 01:52 PM by Belle.)
Post: #307
|
|||
|
|||
RE: Series 9 Episode 8 discussion
BravoNine said: 'I think what WhiteSwan means is that when Lucas said he had been "so careful", he really wasn't that careful if Beth found the real Lucas in seconds and Alec found out where John went to school.
Seems like a silly job of erasing evidence..... ' end quote. If Lucas really didn't remember being John,( can't believe I'm typing this!) than maybe that could explain Beth finding the gym-picture of the 'real' Lucas so fast. If Lucas didn't know he was someone else than there would be no reason for him to think about the fact he would have to cover up his tracks and hiding the existence of a 'real' Lucas North, in this case: destroying the gym-membership-evidence. But as I'm typing this another question comes to my mind: If he didn't know who he really was untill he saw Vaughn/ opened that damned briefcase, why haven't we seen the reason for this total lack of memory? I still find it utterly unlogical and unbelievable that one would be able to completely 'forget' who they really are without 'help', by erasing their memory f.i.. (if it was erased than surely it wouldn't come back simply by looking at a briefcase, would it?), and if it wasn't erased surely Lucas would have caved in wilst undergoing torture in Russia, so there had to be some sort of reference to the fact that the Russians (Darshavin) knew who he was. If I remeber correctly we've never got a hint of that being the case either. And who's past was he talking about then to that boy in 7.6? It had to be Lucas' past, because he told the boy he didn't want to lie to him so he couldn't tell much (being a secret agent), but if it was Lucas' past, there was no reason for John to be secretive about that, since Lucas didn't exist anymore and it didn't matter how much the boy knew. On the other hand, if it was Johns past he was talking about, how could John remember that if we are ment to believe he didn't know anything anymore about being John? I'm sorry if this doesn't come across as coherent, just typing my incoherent thoughts about an incoherent plotline!!! If anyone can shed a light on this, please do! I also want to appologise if this belongs on another thread! It's "a struggle for heaven and earth. Where there is one law: fight or die. And one rule: resist or serve."
|
|||
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
User(s) browsing this thread: 26 Guest(s)